Gamma-ray bursts are the most powerful explosions ever detected in the Universe. They are also one of the greatest mysteries of modern astronomy, since so far there has been no conclusive to prove what causes them. Until now, there have been two 'prime suspects' for what makes gamma-ray bursts: the collision of neutron stars - dead, ultra-dense stars - or the death of very massive stars in supernova explosions. The new results from the XMM-Newton X-ray space telescope rule out the first hypothesis and confirm the second, at least for the gamma-ray burst that occurred on 11 December 2001.
By analysing the afterglow of the gamma-ray burst in the X-ray light, scientists produced the first ever evidence of the presence of chemical elements which were the unmistakable remnants of a supernova explosion which had occurred just a few days before. "We can now confidently say that the death of a massive star, a supernova, was the cause of a gamma-ray burst. However we still don't know exactly how and why these bursts, the most energetic phenomena in the Universe, are triggered," says ESA astronomer Norbert Schartel, a co-author of the original paper, published today in Nature.
Gamma-ray bursts were first discovered in 1967 by chance, when satellites designed to look for violations of the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty detected strong gamma-ray emissions coming from sources not in the vicinity of Earth, but from outer space. They have been a mystery ever since. They occur as often as several times a day but last for no longer than a couple of minutes, and there is no way to predict when or where the next burst will occur. Consequently they are very difficult to study.
For three decades it was not even known whether the explosions were close, in our own Milky Way galaxy, or far away in distant galaxies. But astronomers set up an 'alert system'. This allows them to see the 'afterglow' of the burst before it fades away, by quickly aiming their telescopes at the precise location in the sky shortly after a detector triggers the alert. It is now clear that the bursts occur in galaxies millions of light-years away.
The longest burst
Technically called 'GRB 011211', it was first detected on 11 December 2001 at 19:09:21 (Universal Time), by the Italian-Dutch satellite BeppoSAX. The burst lasted for 270 seconds - the longest one observed by the satellite. A few hours afterwards, when a first analysis confirmed that a burst had indeed been registered, the BeppoSAX team alerted the rest of the astronomical community. ESA's XMM-Newton arrived on the scene 11 hours after the original event. If XMM-Newton astronomers had reacted five hours later it would have been too late; but they were lucky and were able to study the afterglow when it was still 7 million times brighter (in X-rays) than a whole galaxy. This was the third time that XMM-Newton had tried to pinpoint a gamma-ray burst afterglow - the results of the previous two observations were inconclusive.
On this occasion the observations revealed two important facts: first, the material in the source was moving quickly towards Earth, at a tenth % of the speed of light; and second, chemical analysis of this material showed that it had to be the remnant of a supernova explosion.
"We were seeing a spherical shell of material ejected from a very recent supernova, heated by the gamma-ray burst. The fact that the material was coming in our direction means that the sphere was expanding," explains Schartel.
Silicon, sulphur, argon and calcium
XMM-Newton detected large amounts of magnesium, silicon, sulphur, argon and calcium, but very little iron. This is the kind of material a massive star would produce during its latest stages of evolution, just before exploding as a supernova. Nuclear reactions in the star's core fuse light chemical elements into heavier ones, a process that generates the energy needed by the star to shine; different elements are synthesised at each stage of the star's evolution. The supernova explosion would have ejected this material into the surrounding environment, producing the sphere subsequently illuminated by the gamma-ray burst afterglow seen by XMM-Newton.
Astronomers were even able to measure the size of the sphere: 10 thousand million kilometres in radius. With that in hand, and knowing the velocity of the material, they also estimated that the supernova explosion had occurred a few days earlier.
Such a timescale is consistent with the low amounts of iron detected, because this element forms in the material ejected by the supernova only about two months after the explosion itself.
The reason why the neutron star collision hypothesis can be ruled out also stems from these data.
"Such an event wouldn't have expelled sufficient quantities of matter (magnesium etc.) into the surrounding medium to explain what we see," says Schartel.
Moreover, the relatively low amounts of iron could not be explained by the neutron star collision theory. Stars become neutron stars only after exploding as supernovae, but many years - not just a few days - are needed for the object to evolve from one stage to the next.
According to Fred Jansen, ESA's XMM-Newton project scientist, "this kind of study is made possible by the unprecedented collecting area and high sensitivity of XMM-Newton. The Earth's atmosphere prevents X-rays from being detected by ground-based instruments, and no other space telescope in operation could have performed an analysis of equal quality of this gamma-ray burst afterglow. We are now at least one step closer to solving the mystery of these energetic phenomena."
However, many questions remain open in the 'case of the gamma-ray bursts'. Why are all supernova explosions not followed by a burst? What is the precise physical mechanism that triggers the burst?
In October this year ESA is launching a space mission to address precisely these questions. Its International Gamma-Ray Astrophysics Laboratory, INTEGRAL, will be the most sensitive gamma-ray observatory ever launched, able to detect radiation from the most distant violent events.
Note to editors
XMM-Newton, ESA's X-ray Multi-Mirror satellite, is the most powerful X-ray telescope ever placed in orbit. It was launched by an Ariane 5 rocket from ESA's spaceport in Kourou, French Guiana, on 10 December 1999. With its unprecedented sensitivity it observes the X-ray sky, helping to solve many cosmic mysteries, ranging from extremely violent and exotic processes, such as enigmatic black holes, to the formation of galaxies. XMM-Newton also observes celestial objects within our Solar System, such as comets and planets.
The XMM-Newton results are reported in: 'Evidence for outflowing supernova ejects in the afterglow of Gamma Ray Burst GRB 011211' by J.N. Reeves, D. Watson, J.P. Osborne, K.A. Pounds, P.T. O'Brien, A.D.T. Short, M.J.L. Turner, M.G. Watson, K.O. Mason, M. Ehle and N. Schartel, Nature, 4 April 2002.
More information on the ESA Science Programme, including XMM-Newton and INTEGRAL, can be found at: http://sci.esa.int
Information on ESA can be found at http://www.esa.int
For more information please contact:
ESA - Communication Department
Media Relations Office
Tel: +33 (0)1 5369 7155
Fax: +33(0)1 5369 7690
Clovis De Matos - ESA
Science Programme Communication Service
Tel : +31 71 565 3460
Dr Fred Jansen - ESA
XMM-Newton project scientist
Tel: +31 71 565 4426
For further information:
Media Relations Office