Each call for missions usually generates up to 100 responses from academic groups and the mission proposals may cater to astronomy, solar system or fundamental physics research needs.
ESA’s various scientific advisory committees of experts assess the submissions. The committees include the Astronomy Working Group, the Solar System Working Group, the Fundamental Physics Working Group, the Space Science Advisory Committee and the Science Programme Committee. ESA’s engineers also make an initial assessment of the feasibility of the missions.
This effort produces three or four candidates for each mission slot to enter an assessment phase. An ESA scientist and engineer are assigned to each proposal and a one-year feasibility study is undertaken. This identifies any new technology that will need to be developed to make the mission possible. The majority of these studies are conducted internally at ESA’s Concurrent Design Facility (CDF).
How a mission comes to be
Phase 0 | Mission analysis and identification |
Phase A | Feasibility |
Phase B | Preliminary Definition |
Phase C | Detailed Definition |
Phase D | Qualification and Production |
Phase E | Utilisation |
Phase F | Disposal |
Most missions will require some new technology to be developed. This is natural because science is progressive and must advance on previous techniques, but new requirements can pose tough challenges for engineers and spacecraft designers. Sometimes specific circumstances and opportunities allow this potentially lengthy process to be shortened. In the case of Mars Express and Venus Express, spare flight equipment from previous missions made these new missions possible.
The conclusions of all these feasibility studies are presented to ESA’s scientific advisory committees and other scientists, in meetings usually held at ESA headquarters in Paris. The committees then make recommendations about which missions should proceed to ‘Phase A’. Every step that discards proposals is termed a downselect. Usually two or three missions are downselected for the phase A study, for which two competitive industrial contracts are placed for each mission.