Extensions are considered on a case-by-case basis and are approved by ESA's Scientific Programme advisory bodies. The scientific value of the expected return of data versus the cost of extending the mission is a deciding factor in the approval of the extension. For example, in October 2012 ESA’s Integral spacecraft celebrated ten years of science operations – its initial nominal mission was two years.
Turning a satellite off
Not all missions are extended, though. Some consumables may only be sufficient for the nominal mission (i.e. for cryogenic missions), or may have undergone a higher than expected consumption and as a consequence the mission extension is not considered useful. Sometimes before switching off a spacecraft, engineers test certain elements in extreme conditions, in order to achieve useful information for future missions. In the case of ESA's Infrared Space Observatory (ISO), when its sensitive detectors ran out of an essential coolant during its extended mission, the operations team spent a month rigorously testing specific hardware and software systems before finally deactivating the spacecraft. They did this because identical systems were being built into two following ESA missions, XMM-Newton and Integral, which have both benefitted from the information acquired and have been operating for over ten years.
Before terminating the mission, the Mission Operations Centre brings the satellite to a safe orbital position in order to avoid it catastrophically re-entering Earth’s atmosphere. Alternatively, the satellite will be guided through a controlled re-entry, such that the heat generated during the re-entry destroys it, and any remaining small debris falls onto non-populated areas or into the ocean.