Simulation of SMART-1's impact crater
Science & Exploration

SMART-1 impact simulated in a laboratory sand-box

11/09/2006 1240 views 0 likes
ESA / Science & Exploration / Space Science / SMART-1

Laboratory simulations of the SMART-1 impact performed at the University of Kent, United Kingdom, suggest that the impact may have caused a clearly elongated lunar crater, and produced a high-speed rebounding for the spacecraft.

This may help explain some properties of the dust cloud observed just after the actual impact of SMART-1 on the Moon.

The simulations were performed by M.J. Burchell and M.J.Cole at the University of Kent. For the test, they used a high-speed, two-stage light gas gun to shoot at 2 kilometres per second a 2-millimitre aluminium sphere that simulated the SMART-1 spacecraft. The target was a tray of sand, similar to lunar soil.

Light gas gun simulated SMART-1 impact
Light gas gun simulated SMART-1 impact

"We called for such laboratory simulations and numerical modelling of the SMART-1 impact as a crucial test to understand the processes at work in space-bound and artificial impacts," said Bernard Foing, ESA SMART-1 Project Scientist.

Data from a previous project, in which Burchell and Cole made use of coarse grained sand, had shown that for an impact at a 10-degree incidence the fastest ejected material travelled forward (within about plus or minus 5 degree angle with respect to the impact direction) at 120 percent of the impact speed – a higher value than the impacting projectile had.

However, at that 10-degree incidence angle only one percent of the material excavated by the impact went forwards and the percentage decreased as the angle got shallower. Out of that one percent, about 75 percent was at an angle to the surface greater than 10 degrees.

SMART-1 impact sequence by CFHT – the movie
SMART-1 impact sequence by CFHT – the movie

"To reproduce the SMART-1 scenario we simulated an impact at two degrees incidence. The result was a nice non-circular crater," said Mark Burchell. "According to the test's results, the fine grained dust of the lunar surface was to raise a cloud of ejected material, which would have spread out sideways, as well as in a forward direction."

Based solely on the results and ignoring scaling issues, Burchell and Cole predicted the size for the SMART-1 impact crater, expected to be 7 metres long and 4.5 metres wide. This was compatible with ESA’s scaling-law predictions on the size of the SMART-1 crater.

Burchell and Cole also observed a 'ricochet-projectile' phenomenon, suggesting a bounce like that of a single object that had undergone some deformation, with a slight 20 percent loss of speed during the impact.

Impact flash and dust cloud seen by CFHT
Impact flash and dust cloud seen by CFHT

"Based on the latest topography analysis, SMART-1 touched down with a very grazing incidence not higher than a few degrees," said Foing. "Therefore it might have bounced in a similar way to the flying bullet in the sand box, like a stone skipping on water."

"The result of these simulations may explain some of the properties of the clouds detected by the Canada-France-Hawaii telescope (CFHT) up to 100 seconds after the flash," added Pascale Ehrenfreund, coordinator of the SMART-1 impact ground-based observation campaign. "These were spread at some tens of kilometres downstream from impact," she concluded.

For more information

Bernard Foing, ESA SMART-1 Project Scientist
Email: bernard.foing @ esa.int

Mark Burchell, University of Kent, United Kingdom
Email: M.J.Burchell @ kent.ac.uk

Pascale Ehrenfreund, SMART-1 ground-based impact campaign coordinator, Leiden University, The Netherlands
Email: pascale @ strw.leidenuniv.nl

Related Links

SMART-1 impact sequence by CFHT – the movie
Science & Exploration

SMART-1 impact flash and debris: crash scene investigation

07/09/2006 2933 views 5 likes
Open item
Earthrise seen by SMART-1, 29 August 2006
Science & Exploration

SMART-1 swan song: valuable data until final moments

04/09/2006 1264 views 0 likes
Open item
Lunar horizon as seen by SMART-1
Science & Exploration

SMART-1 impact update

03/09/2006 1411 views 1 likes
Open item
SMART-1 - Last moments before impact - simulation
Science & Exploration

SMART-1 impacts Moon

03/09/2006 0 views 0 likes
Open item
SMART-1 trajectory up to impact
Science & Exploration

Impact landing ends Smart-1 Moon mission

03/09/2006 1920 views 8 likes
Open item
SMART-1 star tracker animation, 1 September 2006
Science & Exploration

SMART-1 star tracker views the Moon in earthshine (UPDATED)

02/09/2006 1072 views 1 likes
Open item
Moon phase as expected at SMART-1 impact
Agency

Amateur observers prepare to watch SMART-1 impact

02/09/2006 754 views 0 likes
Open item
SMART-1 impact site - updated impact time
Science & Exploration

Intense final hours for SMART-1

02/09/2006 1280 views 0 likes
Open item
SMART-1 impact area
Science & Exploration

Low altitude flying with coarse maps – determining the time…

25/08/2006 666 views 0 likes
Open item
Lunar view of the SMART-1 impact area
Science & Exploration

Last weekend chance to observe SMART-1 impact site in sunli…

18/08/2006 382 views 0 likes
Open item
SMART-1 impact area
Science & Exploration

SMART-1 impact: last call for ground based observations

17/08/2006 1601 views 2 likes
Open item
SMART-1 trajectory up to Moon impact
Science & Exploration

SMART-1 towards final impact

04/08/2006 2986 views 3 likes
Open item
The Westerbork radio telescope
Science & Exploration

European and worldwide radio telescopes listen to SMART-1

21/07/2006 650 views 0 likes
Open item
SMART-1 trajectory up to impact
Enabling & Support

SMART-1 manoeuvres bring Moon impact to nearside

19/07/2006 633 views 0 likes
Open item
Remote-sensing instruments on SMART-1 scan the Moon's surface
Science & Exploration

The SMART-1 way - giving the Moon some great new looks

12/07/2006 828 views 1 likes
Open item
SMART-1 artist's impression
Enabling & Support

SMART-1 manoeuvres prepare for mission end

23/06/2006 1187 views 0 likes
Open item